Found both uninspiring. It felt more refined (good adjective from above poster) in a cutting sort of way (a bit much for my taste). Re: What is the Duncan humbucker that is most similar to a Lollar Imperial? I bought them as a set, so Ive just kept them together. Is he hiding something. I actually embrace my highs now because the high end that is there is really a pleasure to play with. And like most things guitar-related, it all comes down to your needs and preferences. 1995-2022 Harmony Central, Inc. All rights reserved. The 50s lollar set was even worse than the standard Duncan p90 set, IMO. Reverb from logic. Quote. )I'll try to be strict with it, see if it helps. Based on your influences, definitely a Lollar Imperial. Since their introduction in the 1950s, the 57 Classic has been the ultimate humbucker PAF known for its smooth and velvety tone. Also try d allen rock and blues and bare knuckle Irish tours. I've never owned either brand, but every single guitar I've played with Lollars has sounded REALLY good. A fantastic pickup from a legendary maker, the Seymour Duncan Alnico II Pro does many things well, and is great for blues, jazz, blues rock, and rock. Most Successful Signature Guitar Of All Time? It's a keeper! I'm considering a future upgrade for my SG, and, I'm just taking in all of the options. All rights reserved. JavaScript is disabled. The sound of humbuckers has historically been associated with Gibson guitars, while the single coil tone originates from Fender. Pretty tricky indeed to trust a luthier to work on it ! I can't comment on your topic directly - I have never played Imperials - I just wanted to chime in with my 2c on Duncan '59s.there are a lot of Duncan haters out there, but I'll tell you - I really like the Duncan '59s. I've not compared the two, though I do have a set of '59s in my McCarty and they perform really well in that guitar. I think they sound great, and for 1/2 the price of some of the boo-teek brands, they are a tremendous value as well. Even though the mids are more accentuated, this neck pickup still provides that open air and treble attack of an Alnico 2 bar magnet. I put a 36th PAF in the neck and a Norton in the bridge. I don't know what to tell you. The imperial in the bridge and elrayo in the neck is my favorite combo. Fine pickups but not the vintage sound I like. You could find the Dimarzio 36th for cheap on Ebay. Kelowna BC. Lollar Imperial vs. Bare Knuckle Pickups Stormy Monday in the Eastman SB59! Hey, saw the same post at the LPF, so I paste what I replied there (if that's OK): 59 Duncan's were dark for my taste. I had Burstbuckers in my '06 Les Paul Std. How close they get is subjective, etc. Despite the fact that certain pickups are better for certain types of music or guitar model, keep in mind that rock, jazz, funk, pop, and many other styles are deeply rooted in blues music. check out the FAQ by clicking the Ask the guy I sold a Les Paul Studio which had a set of Fralin P92 in itI offered to switch out the pickups for about 5 or 6 options at the time (including stock Gibson) at no cost and there was no way those pickups were coming out of that guitar. By Surprisingly the Lollar sounds the worst through the Deluxe. DiMarzio has very, very little overlap with Fralin or Lollar. Some of the add-ons on this site are powered by. They are not bright at all and are very balanced and articulate. Sorted my back out. the Seymour Duncan Seth Lovers (Sh-55) vs. AntiquityI'm using my 2011 les Paul R8. Pickups loaded into the same guitar, with the same amp on the same exact settings. Great pickups. The 57 Classic Plus is a slightly overwound version of the 57 Classic. Aug 28, 2020 #1. . High quality is high quality. Overall, this is a great choice for any guitarist, but jazz and blues players will be in vintage heaven with the Lollar Imperial. Sorry I haven't had the chance to compare the pickups you are asking about but I've always found Lollars to be characteristically bright and articulate (in a good way) so I'm surprised you are looking for more clarity (at least in terms of a PAF style). Youll find all these things and more in our roundup of the seven best humbuckers for jazz and blues. The fralin p 90 set I have is the closest to my vintage Gibson. I have not tried the Seymour Duncan Sat Night Special pickups, but they are also A4. There aren't any magic parts that make any PU better than another, not a '59 PAF, not a '51 Broadcaster PU, not a any. I like most of my pups that are all rather generic. I love that magnet as a neck humbucker (bridge as well!). I agree with some other sentiments in this threadthe guitar and rig matter a great deal. Tom. Seymour Duncan SH-4 JB Model Humbucker for Bridge (Zebra) SEY-1200273. Copyright 2022 - Jazz Guitar Online - All rights reserved - Privacy Policy. Excellent product. Mr Wagner is one of the ones I was referring to who is 'lesser known' but playing 'in the same park'Mr BG is another. You are using an out of date browser. This corresponds to an approximate flight time of 0h 57min. If price isnt an issue, the Lindy Fralins are a dream to play with. It's just twangy enough, dry, stripped down and has a decidedly Duncan tone. However, I do have the "You get what you pay for" mindset in, this. Max Guitar B.V.. And you find all of those who offer it. I've owned each of the sets you mentioned, and they're all good, but Lollar's pickups are an order of magnitude better. The Dimarzio Bluesbucker looks like a standard humbucker but provides a P-90 type sound while still canceling the 60-cycle hum effectively. They feature unbalanced coils that produce a tight bottom end that complements the pickup's fullness and causes overtones to build up after each note is played. Lindy Fralin has been a pioneer and innovator in the guitar and bass pickup industry for 30 years, and is one of the most revered boutique pickup creators today. The 59 Model set of pickups has been a favorite among blues, jazz and classic rock players for years. Capture the airy top end, balanced mid-range, tight low end, and beautiful overtones of the classic PAF pickups with the Lollar Imperial humbucker. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. So, if you want classic tones, Loallr and Fralin are much more to taste. Required fields are marked *. Pearly Gates pickups are hand-built in Santa Barbara, California and youll find them in both standard humbucker and trembucker spacing. Train via Marburg Hauptbahnhof 5h 13m. I have SD Antiquity Texas Hots in a strat and love them they are chimey when playing clean and mid-growly when playing overdriven. If I want/need customwound stuff, I still shop for the best bang for the buck. However, what justifies the price difference of a set of Lollar pickups, or Fralins over something from Seymour Duncan or DiMarzio? I got lucky on that pickup and that specific guitar..go figure. I forgot to mention that I also restrung the 175 with TI flats and between the pups and the new strings the guitar has taken on completely different characteristics. The Lollar Imperial humbucker pickups are made with Alnico 2 magnets for the neck position and Alnico 5 magnets for the bridge position. The antiquities are a little rounder and warmer, IMO, not worth the upcharge. Half of the trip is reached in . So now with the Lollars, I am not running away from treble as I would before. pickup. Use Code HIVE25 For 25% Off Select Products! Irony - In my main guitar (a modded two single coil pickup Strat) I have a Lindy Fralin 9.4k overwound pickup with baseplate in the bridge and in the neck I have a GFS Premium Alnico. Not sure it's 100% science though right? Members; 32.4k I tried a variety of buckers over the years including the Duncan JB, 59, Pearly, Alnico II, Parallel Axis and DiMarzios Evo, but the Lollar Imperials is definitely my favorite. It has a low output for a vintage tone, with a smooth grind and a sharp attack. So I ordered a Thornbucker for the neck and Thornbucker Plus 53mm for the bridge. It still has the same Very nice and perfect for Clapton, SRV, Mayer sounds the neck pickup in particular is excellent. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Personally, I recommend the Lollar Imperials as the best all-round humbuckers for jazz and blues. Fralin, Lollar, WCR, etc. Powered by Invision Community. Lollars are wonderful pickups and would work well with what you describe. 36ths are really good, so are pearly gates. Lollar Imperial vs Seth Lover - YouTube 0:00 / 2:35 Lollar Imperial vs Seth Lover Westwood Music 941 subscribers Subscribe 49K views 3 years ago David compares the Lollar Imperial. It may not display this or other websites correctly. 2023: The Year Epiphone Became Unaffordable. These pickups are one of the best options available for humbuckers as they offer great sound, are versatile, and will let your true sound shine through when you play. Wizz Premium Clone In the neck position, this pickup produces a darker clean sound with a vintage touch and is also fantastic for buttery distortion. They have a long history that is still being written today. When it comes to humbuckers, few pickups have the pedigree, history, and tradition of the Gibson 57 Classic. Some of the add-ons on this site are powered by. The magnetism of Joe's '58 Gibson Flying V PAFs measured so high that Seymour Duncan's Custom Shop settled on the unusual choice of using Alnico 6 magnets in order to recreate it. This alone makes it a great option if you are looking for that particular sound in a Gibson-style guitar body. We sell roughly 50% more Lollar standard Imperials than Low Wind and High Wind Imperials combined. They were done for the 50th Anniversary of the humbucker in Duncan's Custom Shop. I can't wait to get the '57 back on the 175. I found the imperials to be smoother then the 59s, I think hifi 59 as somebody else said is a good way to describe it. The pups in my MIJ Blue Flower Tele are stock and they are awesome for that tele tone. 20 weeks to a higher level of proficiency: Howard Roberts Super Chops one more time. My answer is that I have Fralins and Lollars and would not hesitate to spend the money again to get morein fact, just ordered a set of Lollars last week when I came to the conclusion that I was not going to find a set second hand. Lollar Imperials VS. Seth Lovers Lollar Imperials VS. Seth Lovers. Lollar is a brand solely busy with creating the exact pickup that actually fits your desire and the tone that is buzzing in your head. This really is the best of the P-90 sound with the best of a humbucker at an unbeatable price. JavaScript is disabled. I'm thinking the C Rex has something to do with the boxy nasally tone I'm getting with the Deluxe. I was much like you till i had my first set of John Suhr Boutique pickups installed in a Strat.I was amazed how much better they sounded then the same voiced Vintage 60s styled Dimarzios's that they had replaced since then i have given the boutique pickups a chance and not once have i been disappointed.. After re reading your post i think i may have misunderstood your point .. No, what I'm saying is one can't make a blanket statement that one is better than the others. Both jazz and blues players will feel right at home with these humbuckers, as they provide great chord voicing definition for better clarity in the mix. Getting back to best selling Lollar humbuckers: Our standard Lollar Imperial is our best selling humbucker - by far. I have had success with them in Les Paul's, ES-335, PRS Singlecut Trem, PRS SC-245. no. Got the F-Spaced Imperial for the bridge. = They sound great IMO. Was hoping to be knocked over but not so much. guitarcat46April 22, 2011 in Electric Guitars. Starting from Scratch (again) with One Archtop, A chronological approach for learning Jazz. Here's a quick (although not great) comparison between the two pickups. I chose DI because many pickup demos are . Humbucker Shootout: Seymour Duncan Antiquity vs. Lollar Imperial Visual Guy 2.56K subscribers Subscribe 111 13K views 4 years ago Leave a comment on which you prefer and SUBSCRIBE if you. Im one of those guys that runs position 2 for rhythm and bridge for solos. Still the Duncans are really good. I'm doing exactly the same thing right now with a 335. So when he did his signature deal with Gibson, he logically had them load APH's into the prototypes. It's a matter of taste, for which there can be no argument because it is subjective. Aug 31, 2013. I have both and like both in various situations. My favorite humbuckers, although i prefer the standard wind, lightly potted. 6" or 8"? The 57 Classic Plus is the perfect companion for the 57 Classic, and provides a beautiful PAF style fat tone with a vintage flavor for playing blues, jazz, and rock in the vein of the legendary Steve Howe of Yes. Posted March 19, 2009. guitarcapo. It may not display this or other websites correctly. LOLLAR PICKUPS/Imperial No Hole Nickel Cover Set Just some thoughts before you start buying more pickups. I'll just have to order a set, and let my ears be the judge! My only advice is to find a good A4 neck pickup. The Lollar Imperial humbucker pickups are made with Alnico 2 magnets for the neck position and Alnico 5 magnets for the bridge position. Same guitar, same modeler, same patch, same settings. I remember back in the day when Dimarzio was just about the only aftermarket pickup maker out there. The Lollars sounded and felt a lot more musical, more dynamic. However, I'm wondering how much of a tone difference you are getting from a set of these higher priced competitors? I play in a classic rock/jam band and want to upgrade my CS Strat 60's pickups. Its worth it to remember that whats important is making music, regardless of the style, how you play, what guitar you play, and all the other limitless variables. The Pearly Gates is easily one of the best available humbuckers for blues. Your email address will not be published. The driving time is approx. They are smooth in the midrange and kind of warm overall, but I tend to like more clarity in humbuckers so there's less of a jump between that and single coils. Had a regular Duncan in a lapsteel, as it was all that would fit, really liked it and thought the antiquities have done right by me. I've had multiple sets of both, the seths are definitely hotter sounding than the antiquities, even though the sets I had were almost identical in output. But if there was no difference why would Duncan and DiMarzio both have custom pickups that cos as much or exceed the price of Fralin,Suhr or Lollar pickups? Is this Mark Whitfield's new D'Angelico??? Thanks SOLR - Thanks for sharing that link, I'll definitely check that out. Whether you go completely clean or prefer a saturated sound, these pickups will do the job well. Get on the list for don mare supersports. It all depends on your personal tonal needs. Guitar "feel". I've never compared the two but I have played them. I've managed to coax a pretty decent sound out of the Princeton. I've had some nice e-mail responses to pickup questions I've had from Lollar recently. Well a bit of an update, I pulled the Lollars out and put a couple Dimarzios that I had sitting around in the guitar. More sharing options. . Is this Mark Whitfield's new D'Angelico??? So many factors to which pup is best in a particular axe. I don't know if we know each other but we should get in touch because i love that stuff (don't hesitate to drop by Nice ones, thanks for sharing ! Lollar vs Klein P Pickup Discussion in 'Pickups & Electronics [BG]' started by FirewalZ, Aug 28, 2020. IMO: clarity and bite is amazing in Antiquities. If I could get a set tomorrow for that I'd go to the bank machine right now. Thanks Ekam Sat Tags: None Rex_Rocker Ultimate Tone Slacker Join Date: Feb 2015 Posts: 2834 #2 I have Surfers and love them. So, check out the above picture. No, I've never played a strictly jazz guitar festival. With so many gear choices for your guitar, it is easy to get lost in all of this. I don't get into the corksniffery boutique pickups because they are pretty pricey and for no particular reason, but after my experience with Kinman I'd put his pickups high on any list. Lollar Imperial Set CH 7 Pickup Set for Electric Guitar Humbucker Vintage output The silky treble, balanced mid range, tight basses and complex harmonics of the classic original PAF pickups but with an improved design for a more balanced frequency response The bridge tone is fuller while the middle position is cleaner and brighter I use a GT8 model, but the basics are all the same. https://reverb.com/item/2402941-newoped-strat-pickup-set-big-dipper-stratocaster, 2023: The Year Epiphone Became Unaffordable. Put a Seymour Duncan up for $60 including shipping and you'll get offers all day long for $45 and $50. He must be because they are the best pickups by a fair bit and I have tried a {censored}load. That guitar just blows me away every time I play it. I hope this is not out of order but I recently put a WCR Cherrybucker in the bridge of my old PRS and I can't believe how great it sounds. The Vocal EQ Chart (Vocal Frequency Ranges + EQ Tips), EQ Before Or After Compression? You should be able to lower the action by adjusting the bridge thumbwheels provided your neck is properly adjusted. Considering either the Lollar Blackface (have and love em in my old strat) OR the Seymour Duncan Antiquity Surfers (tried them one and sounded great, especially the extra hot bridge pup). . There are even Strats with two humbuckers. never heard a bad thing about the 36s. Today, there are a plethora of options for both pickups and more. yeah, that might have been because of a massive typo. I'm not saying the Fralins or Lollars are worse or even, I'm saying it all depends on what the person wants. Seymour Duncan SH-1N 59 Model Humbucker for Neck - Single Conductor (Black) SEY-1200217. Most Successful Signature Guitar Of All Time? This pickup uses USA-made Alnico 2 magnets for vintage tonal balance and output as well as Lindy Fralins Sectioning technique for unique, dynamic playing and sound. The Pure PAF is a 50s PAF clone and Lindy Fralins favorite humbucker pickup. What's weird is last week I replaced the cheap Armstrong pickups in my D'Angelico EX-SS with the same Lollar pickups and it sounds worlds better. True to its name, the 57 Classic Plus is a true classic that will shine in overdrive or clean on most Gibson type guitars. I still don't understand it. There aren't any magic parts that make any PU better than another, not a '59 PAF, not a '51 Broadcaster . And, more windings means more top-end roll off and less chime and twang. I actually recently got a set of Imperials, the regular version, for a Warmoth Soloist project. The Duncan Antiquities are also excellent pickups. Gear: Fender MIJ Sting Signature DI through Apollo Duo. I was thinking about it today, how can this be? The lower output is clearer and squishy and is great with cleans and low to mid gain. I have not read much bad about them and since you had good experiences on one guitar with the same pickup that is unusual. DA building custom made instruments, the guy who ordered it could also have said "no please don't do the black overlay thing", Hi Mark, But there is absolutely nothing about Fralin or Lollars materials or process that anyone can't replicate. Perhaps you want a humbucker set that offers versatility for various styles? It offers a beautiful clean tone with incredible versatility. $230. The PRRI has the same 5751 in V2 and I'm awaiting the arrival of a Weber 10F150 to replace the stock speaker with. 476. Wanting something that will sound sparkly and clean w/ no gain, but then will have a nice squish to it with some OD/Fuzz. The suits wanted nickel and gold for marketing purposes, looking more elegant than Fender. PV59 are nice pickups, note definition and vintage flavoured all day long. (Heres The Real Answer), 5 Creative Sound Design Tips To Make You Rethink Effects, Sample-Heavy Approach To Production (Interview With BCee), Out-Of-The-Box Experiments (w/ Kamikaze Space Programme), Is Tape Undergoing A Renaissance? Years later, rock musicians found the value of pulling off the covers. I have taken out Duncans from several guitars-----59s as well as JBs, Replaced them with Lollar Imperials, a couple different versions of WCRs and also Dr Vintage by Wolfetone. I have Lollar Blackfaces in my strat. I've had both pickups in the same guitar and much preferred the Lollars. It's absolutely incredible how many choices are availble for aftermarket pickups in all price levels these days. Each of our humbucker models is available in eight different "finishes.". I like them but don't love them, if that makes sense. This model is quickly becoming a modern classic, and for good reason. I'd rather have the Lollar Imperial. I tend to buy small winders, because they wind each PU to fit my needs and guarantee it or they';ll rewind until it's perfect. Not every instrument is available there to make the perfect tone by cooperating with your musical sense. It was built with the original Gibson PAF specifications that provide low volume but with modern clarity. Best mix of the two I've come across outside of the Bonamassa set. It comes with unique tonal variations that provide more midrange than typical humbuckers from a Les Paul guitar from that era, as well as a warm and spongy low end. This pickup is characterized by a warm sound and has a four-conductor cable to facilitate a variety of switching configurations. They were originally developed to solve the hum issue that single coil pickups often present. I wouldn't be looking at either of those if you're after SRV and JM. Not as warm and sweet sounding but more of a bright and fuller sound. Pretty tricky indeed to trust a luthier to work on it ! interesting, what is the rear overlay? You may have to register Interesting you brought up that comparison because the 59 has a very specific tone IMHO. They feature unbalanced coils that produce a tight bottom end that complements the pickups fullness and causes overtones to build up after each note is played. Add to cart. Probably better for playing more modern music and more versatile for me now anyways. The height of the pickups is relative the same. i've tried one snakehead and totally felt for it but it was too expensive for my jazz youngster wallet. This increases the output, making it ideal to use in the bridge position. Most Successful Signature Guitar Of All Time? Members; guitarcapo. I like the Lollar's in some cases. Seymour Duncan's Antiquity range finds itself on most pickup roundups and with good reason. The 59 Model takes a beloved sound from a great old model and manages to make it even better! (Gibson, D'Angelico, Trenier) ANSWERS, 1970s Aria PE-190 Robert Conti w vintage gold Dearmond 1100 pickup. 1998 HERITAGE H-575 archtop guitar w/Spruce top - EUR 2.593,12. DC: Neck 7.6K, Bridge 8.4K Low Wind Imperial Humbucker JB sound too different to compare with the other 2. and again the cost goes upbut you need a Rickenbacker toaster Pu in a humbucker case, they'll do it! This is a premium choice pickup with a very musical tone that jazz and blues players will adore. (Gibson, D'Angelico, Trenier) ANSWERS, 1970s Aria PE-190 Robert Conti w vintage gold Dearmond 1100 pickup. Do you want to play modern blues ala Joe Bonamassa?